Bob - you are right - never say never. Each case demands a separate assesment.
The point is that many boats are abandoned prematurely and this error plays out with amazing frequency.
In a storm senario (much different than fire) a raft is not a "safe" place to be. Rafts tear, tumble, and are very dangerous places, they are a last resort. A partially flooded boat with broken windows and no power can be safer than a raft.
That said your point is a good one - "you just have to evaluate the conditions at hand"
Hopefully none of us will ever need to make those evaluations
k4 - US Patent No: US D588,518 S
"It is not necessary to change; survival is not mandatory" - Edward Deming
Team Man Made Climate Change is real.
John Huntsman December 2011 . . . . . "When we take a position that basically runs counter to what 98 out of 100 climate scientists from what the National Academy of Scientists said on what is causing climate change, and man’s contribution to it, I think we find ourselves on the wrong side of science"