I've listened to the disc 4 or 5 times now.

The instrumentals are tight and sound awesome! It doesn't stray from the recipe, and it covers the old sounding VH stuff to the newer. If Eddie tried anything new, it was brief and un-noticed. Grade: A for diehards. B to B+ for those who expected something else.

David sounds fine if he stays away from the high notes.
I can only assume he's responsible for the lyrics in these songs. Some just have that weirdness in them I associate with his solo days. He's trying to pack too many words in at times and has to speed through parts. Grade: B+ for still having the capacity.

I like this disc more for the Eddie side than the Dave side. Songs like Tattoo sounds great, but the goofy lyrics cripple the song. Sounds Frosty gets good, but I have to listen to Dave go UH UH UH UHUH UHUH UH UH like a fire alarm buzzer first. There's 4 songs I'd flush just for these annoying traits.

Bottom line: It's definitely better than nothing, but it's nothing new.